holly's profile picture

Published by

published
updated

Category: School, College, University

ai use REQUIRED in STEM class

project description

i'm an engineering major and one of my classes has a project worth 5% of the final grade about making an ai generated music video. if you saw my last blog post, you know how much i hate ai, so obviously i don't want to do this project!

the project description is at the top of this post... idk how it will show up for you. i highlighted the parts i have problems with. i don't like group projects, especially ones where we have to write a song, but id much rather do it without ai!!! especially since it's a group of ten people, that makes it easier, and honestly it could be so much fun. 

i am THIS CLOSE 🤏to writing an essay five paragraph email to my professor! i want to tell her:

1. ai is unethical because it steals from artists and writers! it’s not creative or original, in fact it discourages creativity and originality, which is the opposite of what we should be doing as aspiring engineers. (i have two sources for this point)

2. it's TERRIBLE for the environment! your students will be LITERALLY BUILDING the future and we should be practicing sustainability, not contributing to 1 damaging the environment and 2 the normalization of something so damaging. (another two sources here)

3. ai is bad for your brain, it discourages thoughtfulness and erodes critical thinking skills! i know you want us to fact check the generated lyrics, but again, this assignment normalizes the use of and dependence on ai, which decreases critical thinking abilities. as people involved in education, we should be doing the opposite! (and another source :3)

4. i took a class w her last semester and it was great so i'll compliment her about that in the beginning, and at the end i'll suggest other types of projects to replace this one. that way it doesnt look so much like i'm just complaining to complain

am i too woke?? am i making a big deal out of nothing? 


2 Kudos

Comments

Displaying 3 of 3 comments ( View all | Add Comment )

CatsSpats

CatsSpats's profile picture

Absolutely make a stink about it. I’ve had a few very pro-AI classes in university so far and all of them drove me completely batty. My worst offender was an entire class on using AI in teaching. It was saying things like “student productivity with AI is so much more than without!” Like WDYMM, when I’m a teacher I want my students to think for themselves and not be reduced to the amount of work they produce!!


Report Comment



i would NOT survive that class WTF i cringe every time my professors mention ai in a good way. i'm scared for the kids of the future bc youre absolutely right, why are they prioritizing productivity over thinking for yourself???

good news my class though!! she put out an announcement: "If you have strong objections to using AI tools (for personal, ethical, or religious reasons), you may complete the project without AI. Please contact me in advance so that we can arrange an appropriate alternative." i'm sooo relieved

by holly; ; Report

Mulch Lover

Mulch Lover's profile picture

Not an overreaction, blow up that class


Report Comment



update!!! my professor made an announcement:

"If you have strong objections to using AI tools (for personal, ethical, or religious reasons), you may complete the project without AI. Please contact me in advance so that we can arrange an appropriate alternative."

i'm so relieveddd

by holly; ; Report

holly

holly's profile picture

here's the image of the project description in case yall cant see it:
https://gcdnb.pbrd.co/images/k7h1hxT6UwT0.png?o=1


Report Comment