Opinion time

I disagree when people say LizardStripe or Rainflower should've gone to the DarkForest, Yes they were bad mothers but they never broke the code. [Also I love LizardStripes quote "Oh, yes? What a miracle. If I'd known toms could have kits, I would have made Mudclaw have these brats of mine himself."

MapleShade is overrated, I like her to but damn. She shouldn't be forgiven either.

Disabled cats are dumped into the medicine den / Elders den too much, Of course it's fine sometimes but they have more use!!

I feel like BlueStars death was rushed, And she should've had more redemption to StarClan first.

I adore YellowFang and her book <3 Her story is so sad

Baby TigerStar (First arc) was adorable

If you wanna debate on these then sure :P