I've been stuck in my creepypasta phase for a long time now and it's really hard finding good fanfics so Imma list out the ones I found really intriguing!! X3!! I'll be listing out ones from Quotev and Wattpad. (Disclaimer: I have really bad commentary skillz.)
- Freaks [Reader x Proxies]
Author: feisty (teaheart)
The characters are well-thought out and the plot is well-structured! It's a slow burn and it has a bunch of wholesome moments!! I love that the author didn't base Toby's character all on his trauma. They really went in-depth with all the proxies' personalities! Easily one of my favorite fanfics ever!!!https://www.quotev.com/story/14741613/Freaks-Reader-x-Proxies/1
- 365 Days (Eyeless Jack x Reader)
Author: Peaches (Peaches04)
- To Live Without Fear (Jeff the Killer x Reader)
Author: JCreepsIf you're into the classics, this one is perfect. It got me feeling like I was in a music video and it was just soo fun to read. The reader is competent and Jeff isn't a complete jerk!
- Spill Your Guts (Proxies x Reader)
Author: Abby, Rea (ItsABee, whyamiathing)
- The Hunt is On (EJ, Jane the Killer, Clockwork x Reader)
Author: Abby, Rea (ItsABee, whyamiathing)Okay, another one by the same authors. Personally, I like fanfics where Slenderman isn't like a father figure and more like a vicious entity and this story just has that. While Jeff is the main antagonist of this story, Slenderman also pops up in situations and just makes the story a lot more interesting!.
- The Game (Jeff the Killer x Reader)
Author: CuteHybristophiliacThis fanfic is actually kinda wild. Jeff is not nice at all. This one is not for everyone. It goes through deep psychological abuse and might be triggering for some. I didn't like Jeff at all and just stayed for the plot. It's one of those "Do you really like it, or do you like it cause of nostalgia?"
- The Patient (F. Reader x Homicidal Liu)
Author: Hana (hana555)
- Chains (Eyeless Jack x Reader) -
A classic. I read this a long time ago and it's one of the most memorable creepypasta stories I've read. Can't say much about it right now, but I took a great liking to the author's portrayal of EJ. I need to reread x3.
- Playing Favorites (Ticci Toby x Reader)
Author: Sowfi (LetterToJane)
The relationship is really complicated and it pulls on your heartstrings a lot. Honestly, I can't remember anything about the plot since I read this a long time ago but I remember liking it a lot.
I'll add more in the future!