Many of those people who have ever read Gielen say that he is hard to digest and understand. I think that these difficulties are not related to the fact that the material and the ideas are hard, but that Pascal himself does not know how to structure his own thoughts properly. One of the main problems personally for me is that he is not proposing any proofs or arguments for his theses. Also, he seems to enjoy a lot to restructure thoughts of other people who he prefers to quote.
Many things that he is describing seem very similar to "The Death of the Artist" by Bill Deresiewicz. I got the impression that Gielen made very messy notes on this book and added his own opinion about hating capitalism. Actually, "Creativity and other fundamentalisms" is ideal for those who hate capitalism but at the same time have no idea how to form an argument and just want to convince everybody around them that this form of economy is to be blamed for everything that is wrong with this world.
In the last chapter, he is forming a line of thoughts regarding creativity and that it is formed by a harmony of participating in society and being isolated (the last thing being the one which helps to objectively analyse the reality). Pascal is convinced that group work is made specifically to awaken competitive feelings within us. Using that, neoliberalism "takes everything under its control", and this scheme is used as a tool during the formation of social media; that is why we have an Internet addiction... Not gonna lie, it sounded to me like "women's friendship is non-existent due to natural desire to compete". Source (any statistics, further research)? Made up, perhaps.
Among these mostly randomised and unstructured texts, I personally found for myself a familiar, but quite interesting complaint regarding the modern world, and it's a constant need to move and update. There is a lot of research about it that explains the need of capitalism to trap us into a stream of updates and the feeling of wasted time, but this strategy is mostly used to make the consumption process even faster. Pascal Gielen tends to think that this process is made mostly to stop creative people from finding time to think creatively. People who are constantly working or are online do not have any time for their hobbies. I partially agree with this thought; however, I do not think that this is the main goal of capitalism or neoliberalism: only a pleasant bonus in the form of a consequence of this system.
Apparently, Pascal Gielen does not like the phenomenon of making culture something that can be private. Sounds confusing for me personally, since he does not specify at all what he means by the term 'culture'. In times of globalisation, creative people tend to spread their art on the Internet; as a result, they are trying to target a global audience. Obviously, capitalism is responsible for that; however, cultural globalisation is not a problem per se: the problem is that you cannot earn any money from that.
He also specifies a realistic problem of shifting systematic mistakes and blaming a specific person. That actually works pretty well on people with no critical thinking ('not all russians' narrative, for instance). However, this part is not filled with arguments and does not make a connection to the phenomenon of creativity at all. You just start to question yourself regarding the usefulness of everything that is ever written in this book.
Comments
Displaying 0 of 0 comments ( View all | Add Comment )