TÏlda's profile picture

Published by

published

Category: Web, HTML, Tech

D.H.H. is the embodiment of hype

I'll ignore the things he said about foreigners coming to the UK and just focus on the software side of things. Don't take me seriously, my opinion IS NOT fact. Also if I get anything wrong, please correct me :3


So he made Ruby on rails, a framework for the Ruby language for anyone uninitiated. That's completely fine, I'm all for innovation, nevermind the fact that Ruby is awfully slow. From what I know he, along with most Ruby programmers at the time, loved MacBooks which retrospectively makes sense.

Then, what pisses me off the most is his blog
[Let the agents democratize open source]
Which already reeks of bad takes. I would like to go over said bad takes for a "short" moment

- "The open source movement spent decades fighting for everyone's right to change software, through free access to code and permissive licenses to release improvements. But at the dawn of the AI revolution, as this mission is finally being broadly fulfilled, it's clear that "everyone" never actually meant everyone to some."
- This is the general theme of the entire blog. That OpenSource is not accessible enough and in my opinion that's for the better. We're seeing the effect of allowing anyone to make anything as you're reading this. AI generated JS+React slop dominates the industry and no one is happy about it. For FOSS to succeed you don't just have to make your code OpenSouce. The program itself actually needs to be good. No one is going to use a file manager or music player that eats up a gigabyte of RAM just because it has a MIT license



- "Projects big and small have been erecting new participation barriers on contributions aided by AI to preserve the privileges of the old programmer guilds. This is a protectionist tale as old as time. And the justifications are just as tired: It's about quality! It's about attribution! It's about workers! Spare me. It's about you, your insecurities, and your privileges."

- Not every project wants AI code to infiltrate their codebase and that's their own policy. At the same time, OpeSource allowing AI is fine it's their policy as well. If you have a problem with either, fork it. You don't just come into someone's house and do things the way you see fit

- "Humans have been writing shitty software, with dodgy attribution and plenty of bugs, since five minutes after the profession materialized. Agents aren't perfect, slop is a problem, but giving more people the power to enjoy malleable computers is undoubtedly a huge win for the founding vision of open source. "
- I don't want this to all be arguing for the sake of arguing so I will include to full paragraph and say that D.H.H. does have a point here. Slop is a problem and AI isn't perfect. But also, while software has never been 100% perfect that amount of bad software before was definitely lower because not everyone could be a programmer and there were many more hardware restrictions on computers of that era. Today you'd just say it's the users fault and tell them to buy more RAM in an already broken economy

- "But as with so many social movements that purport to fight for freedom or equality, this AI backlash reeks of status games, envy, and what Nietzsche called ressentiment: How dare you make or change software without suffering through all that I had to endure learning this trade! This precious power is my reward for enduring the social humiliation of being a nerd!"

- Point of advice: bringing up Nietzsche makes you sound pretentious. Anyways Using AI models by giant companies that already have a bad track record to respecting your privacy and are blurring the legal lines of licenses is pretty anit-FOSS, no?

Lastly, there's Omarchy just... existing. This a personal pet-peeve of mine so I won't bring too much attention to this but opinionated software like Omarchy always puts user control at a disadvantage because it's, well, opinionated. Then there's the absurd amount of money the project is getting which is suspicious, the fact that it was initially opinionated but beginner friendly and then turned to being "agentic", that it comes with Basecamp preinstalled which is a company D.H.H. co-founded, issues with Docker, etc...

Just to sleep easy at night and not have my house raided and my head torn off, let me clarify that if you like D.H.H. then more power to you. This was just MY take

 /\___/\
( 0 vv 0)


0 Kudos

—

Comments

Displaying 0 of 0 comments ( View all | Add Comment )