mommy asmr tier list

S tier:
sora asmr. unique scripts, idk if she writes her own or has a ghostwriter or just picks very niche scripts but this is one of the biggest reasons i put her in s tier. her scripts tend to be a lot more realistic too and that really adds to the experience and immersion factor. good voice, good mic, and very consistent uploads from her. PLUS she has longform 1 hour+ asmrs, and those are some of the best to fall asleep to. overall she's absolutely the best.

vembressa asmr. niche pick but only femboy asmr ive actually enjoyed. i put them in s-tier because while i don't listen to them often, if i'm in the mood for some gay shit they the goat. also they've got the vocal range to do both femboy AND mommy asmr, which is impressive. as far as just raw vocal talent goes, vembress ought to take s tier.

A tier:
alekirser. she does the same / very similar reddit scripts to many other people but she's got a very high quality mic and  funny delivery / humor. ALBEIT. she doesn't upload as much as i'd prefer.

anniepants. i don't listen to her a TON but she puts out great work and I've never listened to an audio that was bad from her.

clem whispers. she uploads very often and does reddit scripts like most others, but she churns them out consistently and has a nice voice. she's basically like sora ASMR if she did reddit scripts instead of having a ghostwriter imo. 


B/C/F tier: i'm lumping these tiers together as there isn't enough of them per tier to warrant much more granularity. misc creators / ones i haven't listened to much of will be here.

bethyVA. i'm putting her at the highest in this tier. she does have a great voice, and i think her content is overall good, but the writing is VERY romance-anime and cliche. she's never been my go-to for the writing, but she does have a nice voice. 

mae asmr. she's mostly known from ~2022/2023 early era mommy asmr, and she hasn't been all that popular in a long while. still, she puts out content, and in making this list i listened to a little bit of her and it doesn't seem too bad, but she's certainly a product more of her time. 

finally, my least favorite (popular) creator:

mamayunya. her placement here at the bottom might be controversial, but FRANKLY a lot of her work has become TOTAL GOONBAIT. at one point i loved her asmrs, especially her older pre-horny era ones, and she does STILL have a nice voice. the problem here is scripts and the way she modulates her voice with her characters. they've become more like exaggerated caricatures to me than believable people. some of her audios are genuine brainrot and anytime i try to listen to her i genuinely laugh out loud sometimes at the lines. this is part of her appeal in one way, so i wouldn't call her a bad creator by one bit, but she's just not my favorite. if this was a gooning tier list, she might be S tier, but for mommy asmr, which in my mind is supposed to be more comforting than sexual? its what puts her down here. if you need a laugh though this is probably the funniest to listen to: but the problem is you're laughing at her more than with her. tldr: despite being in the game for a VERY long time (i can remember listening to her 3-4 years ago) she's unfortunately downgraded over time imo. she does drop rare bangers though, and i have to respect her for sticking around this long and becoming one of the most popularly subscribed to creators.

chime in with your own opinions here if you're a fellow enthusiast, or maybe put me on more creators i might not know of!