so, hi! i’m lucia and i think it’s important to state my mental health issues, since a few of them are quite romanticized, while others are extremely negatively viewed.
so, i have audhd and extreme ocd, both of which are fairly “destigmatized” (in quotes for a reason i’ll explain later!), and lots of people do understand what it’s like to have those, or have lots of sympathy and understanding.
however, i also have histrionic personality disorder, a cluster b disorder characterized by an EXTREME need for attention and EXTREME attention seeking behavior, basically basing your personality off of how you think you’d get the most attention.
destigmatizing
lots of people want to destigmatize mental health, wanting people to be free to get the help they need without extreme judgement or an impact on their life. this is a wonderful goal, and i have nothing but respect for ppl who TRULY want every (or most) mental illnesses to be destigmatized in this way. i do believe that everyone deserves to get help without the fear of ruining their life, and deserves people around them who understand and try to accommodate their struggles.
this is something that has happened a lot recently, notably with autism, adhd, ocd, and depression. people are extremely understanding and forgiving, and will be quick to talk about how important mental health is.
but, this can become a problem.
romanticizing
romanticizing comes in when people want some mental illnesses, or when they see them as some attractive or desirable trait. for example, i’ve seen many people say they “want” ocd, because they want to be more neat or organized, without fully realizing what ocd entails.
this happens with lots of conditions, and i’ve seen this happen a LOT with bpd recently, but since i don’t have that, i wont speak on how harmful that may be.
however, at least for ocd, this is incredibly hurtful. i am so incredibly paranoid on a day-to-day basis that i can barely leave the house, i need to check locks constantly, and i never truly feel safe. but people romanticizing it as being neat, being organized, or being meticulous really harm the perception of it, it takes so long to explain to someone what my ocd entails and what support i might need, since the people who romanticize it have popularized this idea that ocd is just some want to be neat, not an overpowering illness.
lack of care
frankly, many people who claim they want to support people with mental illnesses or want to destigmatize them, simply don’t care at all.
i’ve had so many people claim to be ok with my hpd or want to help me with it, but if i’m ever too attached, exhibit attention seeking behavior, etc., they turn their backs or get annoyed/angry. this isn’t excusing my behavior! obviously i understand not wanting someone who’s quite manipulative and attention seeking as a friend, it genuinely makes sense. what doesn’t make sense, is claiming you want to destigmatize illnesses and support those who have them, while turning around and doing quite possibly the worst thing you could to do someone with hpd who you claimed you wanted to “help”.
i don’t expect everyone to be accommodating for everything, you just can’t be. i don’t expect everyone to like me or be able to deal with me. what i do expect is for people to tell the truth, to mean what they say. be honest with yourself and with whoever you want to support, don’t drop them when it becomes too much.
i know it seems like i have lots of vitriol with this, but ive had friends commit suicide because of lack of support from people who claim they supported those with mental illnesses. it does real harm to lie and fake your support for people.
the romanticization of certain conditions being branded as “destigmatization” is extremely damaging, it means that some people will be seen as deserving of respect and support in our society, while others deserve to be stigmatized or disrespected, since they don’t have the mental illnesses that we consider to be destigmatized.
conclusion
i know this is a long and rambly and sort of angry sounding post, but i feel extremely strongly about this, and i don’t want anyone else to lose their life because they believe they’re so broken that they can’t even be accepted by people who claim to support mental health.
if you want to do something about this, stand up for people. if you see someone romanticizing, stop them, correct them as best you can. be mindful of how you speak about certain illnesses. and most importantly, don’t lie. be honest about if you can support someone or not, it’s understandable to not have the mental capacity to support everyone you meet, but it isn’t understandable to lie.
thanks so much for reading <3 this is extremely important to me, and i hope you learned something or at least understand my viewpoint.
Comments
Displaying 4 of 4 comments ( View all | Add Comment )
CatsSpats
I know this was posted a while ago, but I ran across it and I wanted to say that I absolutely agree with you on this (I actually wrote my college writing essay on this topic, haha).
I think that social media plays a really big role in all of this. On social media, if you're not part of a marginalized group, it's often hard to participate in certain conversations and be taken seriously. Some of that is valid, but it can sometimes get out of hand. In order to find communities, participate in conversations, and have a say in the suffering Olympics that are always going on, then it's pretty easy to say you've got xyz just to get in. Nobody can prove you wrong, and you don't have to go through all the crap that these disorders bring with them.
I'm currently being medicated and treated for suspected OCD, and let me tell you that this entire thing of people romanticizing it online (and honestly sometimes in person) has been AWFUL. I stress ALL THE TIME that I'm just faking it for attention, that I'm lying to my psychiatrist to get a diagnosis to seem cool, and that I'm just as bad as everyone who does this. It isn't just affecting my externally anymore; it's infiltrated my mind. AAAH.
MZIH
I couldn’t reply to replies so it’s here. Even tho a lot of what I said is in agreement with yours and I’m glad you care to see it this way, but “(selfies) mental illness be damned, i’m hot!” is contradictory to this post and I can’t let it slide. I understand if it’s sarcasm, then my comment there is sarcastic in tandem. But if it’s just compulsive, then not only does it just contradict you on romanticizing, but you also self-validate (“I’m hot”). That is why I don’t indulge it but mock it, and I’m sick of diluting my mockery because I’m sick of diluting consequence—hence I brought this up. This is just to say that you aren’t excused from my scrutiny just because you agree with me, but neither am I.
MZIH
As someone with neurodivergent disorders (which naming is irrelevant), nothing is more abhorrent than romanticizing it, because it comes from delusion and not understanding. Destigmatizing is the closest thing to understanding, but it has been so politicized and virtue signaled that the point is not understanding but looking good. To me it is an obstacle to overcome, even though it’s unfair that some people don’t have to overcome; life is full of self-overcoming and unfairness, and that is why I don’t try to overcome just to be normal. Continuously striving to improve is an end goal. The key difference between “destigmatizing” and understanding is that I understand why there is a compulsive need to get attention, but I also understand how meaningless it is as a way of life and value. I condemn the behavior and not the person because they can be dissociated, even tho I sound mean while doing it. I condemn because the carrier should also understand the issue, and understanding is on the path of overcoming. This is also a rant for those who are ignorant to disorders and those with disorders who are complacent because of societal acceptance. People must accept people with these setbacks, but not mental disorders themselves as virtue/excuse.
Unless of course this is an excuse at getting attention all by itself, which you could’ve done a better job.
i think you phrased this better than i did (but is mostly what i meant to say)
i don’t think we should just say “oh if you’re nd, you shouldn’t try to change at all!” imo destigmatizing is just recognizing that some people do have these issues, and may need special help / more support.
by lucia; ; Report
to add (idk why comments can’t be edited)
the person with the issue should recognize it and actively work on improving, there shouldn’t be a point where someone just becomes complacent with their issues
also.. this is not just a way for me to get attention lol, it’s just rly important to me!
by lucia; ; Report
clover - ⋆。°✩
this is all so real. i've been told by two mental health professionals that i have "developing BPD" which is medical speak for "you have it but you're 16 so we can't diagnose you legally". it has literally ruined all my relationships and my life in general. i think people who say they wish they had so and so probably have never interacted with someone who has a disorder that makes them behave badly. it's always "i want bpd" or "i wish i had ocd" until someone with those disorders starts actually showing symptoms (mood swings, anger, anxiety, ect). they just don't understand, plain and simple.
exactly. i’ve had someone say they wish they had hpd since it tends to make ppl extremely social, outgoing, and charismatic, but they conveniently ignored the extremely high suicide rate, substance abuse rate, and other horrible side effects of having hpd. people take the good parts and ignore the bad parts.
i’m really sorry you’ve been going through that, i hope you can get properly diagnosed and any help you need soon <3
by lucia; ; Report
tysm!! <3 i hope one day things just all work out and people start to see disorders for what they really are without the judgement that comes with that,, have a nice day/night whatever time it is ദ്ദി ˉ͈̀꒳ˉ͈́ )✧
by clover - ⋆。°✩; ; Report