Is fear and hunger a good game?

while I'm writing this i sill haven't gotten any ending in fear and hunger 1 and havent even played fear and hunger 2 

<----You right now 

Maybe i don't get to really say anything because i haven't played enought but I am trying and ive come to the conclusion that it is not a good game and i have a few reasons to explain why

 THE FUCKING COIN FLIP

having basically everything in the game be decided by a 50/50 is a really dumb decision if it were just the combat i would probably understand but it is for looting and random tiles on the floor AND SAVING?????!?? and there are other ways to save but we will get into that but having the beds mostly be a coin flip is really stupid and shouldnt exist

The skill tree 

leveling up and learning new abillities is confusing difficult and it's very easy to backpedal and lock yourself out of very helpful skills also the outlander having the worst skill tree just basically makes him useless and adds another layer off annoying difficulty which shouldn't matter

Are we playing a rougelike?

having the map change slightly between playthroughs is a great mechanic and having the items change between deaths lets you try lots of different situations and explore the map you get differently everytime you die i think is really fun but the coinflip which i mentioned before just completely ruins it because having to deal with the aspect of not getting anything rather than something different just makes it exaughsting

 Cheating is the only way

using the empty scrolls to give myself items and magic feels like cheating but genuinely feels like the only way to progress and learn somethings because again you can lock yourself out of the magics and affinities 

O LORD

GIVE

BETTER GAME

I hope you liked my rant if you disagree you can spread your cheeks for the elite guards