Now before I get into what I want to say, I need to mention that I have nothing against veganism or vegans. It's none of my business how you live your life, and veganism stems from feelings of sympathy and justice so by no means do I think it is a wrong practice. I'm just using it as an example to go off of.
I believe we tend to think of lives as more "valuable" the closer they are to us biologically. A human life is the most valuable, then comes mammals and birds and fish and such, then comes insects, and the last on our list are plants and fungi. Even veganism, which stems from the thought that all lives should be valuable and we shouldn't kill or farm other species since their lives are just as important, completely invalidates plants and fungi as living organisms of a different species. The assumption that plants cannot feel or perceive their environments and so cannot go through pain for being farmed or killed or harvested honestly has no real basis. When eyes aren't the only way of seeing and echolocation exists, what makes us assume that nervous systems are the only way of feeling? A nervous system is made up of neurons transmitting electrochemical signals, and though plants do not have neurons they still transmit electrical signals to and from different parts of their bodies in response to environmental stimuli. When we can barely even understand a portion of the functioning of our brains, how do we expect to know that these electrical signals are not signaling stress or fear? Just because they do not feel the same way does not mean they do not feel, and just because they do not live the same way does not mean they do not live. So how can we say that their lives are any less valuable, that their dignity deserves any less protection than those of animals?
Then again, another topic I want to discuss is how we think of ourselves as separate from "nature". We are animals, we are a part of nature. We might be an invasive species, but so are common carps and I don't see them worrying about the lives of different species. We might be "more intelligent" than other species (which I think is a wrong description in and of itself but I will leave that alone for now), but we aren't exempt from the cycle of life and neither are we exempt from the necessity to consume other living organisms for survival that any species except for primary producers have.
In the end, what I am saying is not that animals deserve torture and not that vegans shouldn't eat plants. It is simply that all living organisms should be respected to a degree, however we must also recognize that we are one of those organisms and, while torture or excessive pain infliction is unnecessary, consumption of other living organisms is our only method of acquiring the energy we need to live. At least until we learn how to photosynthesize, which I doubt the plants which we disrespect the lives of would be willing to teach us anytime soon lol
Comments
Displaying 3 of 3 comments ( View all | Add Comment )
Fish
Also, adding onto what you were saying, plants have actually been found to emit "screams" inaudible to humans. I learned about this a while ago, so I don't actually remember how it works, but it's still something worth pointing out, and which highlights that plants still go through the same process of pain and death as cows, chickens, etc.
whoa thats so interesting, thank you!! do you still have the article for that? i want to look into it more!
by Eda (≧▽≦); ; Report
Fish
Slay
agus :]
this!!
you put into words what puts me off about veganism. it's that looking at man as separate from nature. imo, separating ourselves from nature is what brings us to see the meat we eat as only a lifeless slab of protein, which allows us to create the cruel animal factory systems vegans protest against.
a lot of hunter gatherer cultures, by virtue of relying on nature to survive, see humans as part of nature. yet all of these cultures eat meat as well. i think eating meat is a necessary part of accepting humans as part of the biosphere
I'm glad you get it!! and i agree on how eating meat is necessary in accepting that we are part of the biosphere!! though there is still a lot more to it, and its pretty hard to fully grasp that with how we live right now regardless of our diet.
honestly posted that blog thinking i was yelling into the void lol rlly happy that someone understood me, thank you!!
by Eda (≧▽≦); ; Report