book log no. 2: the fellowship of the ring — fog on the barrow-downs

BEWARE!

SPOILERS BEYOND THIS POINT!

Esquire on X: "Wood learned about the 'All Right Then, Keep Your Secrets'  meme when strangers started quoting it to him. “I'd completely forgotten  that line. Then people started asking me to





What: The Fellowship of the Ring by J. R. R. Tolkien. pub. 1954.

Where: Book 1 Chapter 8 — Fog on the Barrow-downs

Summary: The beginning of the chapter concludes the four's stay with Tom Bombadil and the departure from the Old Forest, managing to say goodbye to Goldberry when she appears to them on a hilltop overseeing a large portion of the land. Around noon, they stop at a hill with a large standing stone on it, eating lunch in the shade and accidentally falling asleep. They wake up at around sunset in a thickening fog, to which they hurriedly cleaned up their things and mounted their ponies, intent to reach the Road they were traveling on before they took their detour into the Old Forest to avoid the Dark Riders.

They eventually come across two standing stones that stood next to each other, though Frodo only takes notice of them while he passes through what he initially perceives to be the way to the northern end of the Barrow-downs. Immediately, darkness falls around him, and after his pony throws him onto the ground and runs off, he starts calling for the other three. He hears them calling out to him, but it seems very distant, and is followed by a disquieting shriek. And then silence. Frodo, fearful and alone, goes in the direction of the voices, still calling out them as he starts to climb up a hill. He eventually reaches the top, where the darkness starts to let up some, revealing that he went the wrong way. Suddenly, a voice calls out, and Frodo attempts to flee but falls onto the ground. A large figure looms over him, blotting out the stars as they claim that they had been expecting him. They then grab him, their icy grip the last thing he feels before he falls unconscious.

He wakes up inside the barrow sometime later unable to move, and remembering Bilbo, starts to wonder if this is where his adventure ends. He manages to regain mobility not too long after, and he looks around to discover, to his horror, that all four of them were lying next to each other clad in thin pale robes and covered in various jewelry. The other three are unconscious and cold to the touch. Surrounding them is all sorts of treasure, though their appeal is lost on Frodo as he subsequently notices a long sword atop their necks. He starts to hear a haunting incantation as a long arm, crawling on its fingertips, starts to make its way over them from a passage within the room. Frodo contemplates putting on the ring and fleeing without his friends, but he summons his resolve; Managing to stand up, grab a sword, and chop the hand off the arm, breaking the blade. He tries to wake up Merry to no avail, but remembers the song that Tom told them to sing should they find themselves in a situation much like this. Frodo starts to sing, the words strong despite his fear, and he suddenly hears what sounds like Tom singing the next few verses in response from somewhere outside of the Barrow. The wall shatters, daylight pouring in as Tom indeed marches in, revealing the hobbits' captors to be barrow-wights as he casts them away.

He and Frodo get the other hobbits as well as the treasure out into the field, and Tom wakes the three of them up. He informs them that the clothes on their person before the barrow-wights accosted them are pretty much gone, but that they should frolic and celebrate their lives. He departs and shortly returns with their ponies, and after they get dressed they divvy the treasure amongst themselves. He gives the hobbits a dagger each for self-defense. Tom then leads them out to the Road, talking about the landscape as well as the kingdoms that once inhabited them. Upon finally reaching the Road, he directs them to their next destination—a village called Bree. Specifically, a pub within the village known as The Prancing Pony, and in addition, he instructs them to talk to a Barliman Butterbur. Despite the hobbits' pleading for him to stay one more night with them, he gently refuses and encourages them to be on their way, saying that he's reached the bounds of his country and that he must return to Goldberry.

The chapter ends with the hobbits hurriedly running into Bree.

Thoughts: wow! so uh. eventful chapter here. i was having a hard time trying to make sure the summary was good and relatively accurate while also trying to stick to being concise, but i think i managed. i think it's about to get more eventful, though, as i'm suspecting that i'm going to get to meet aragorn next and i know that he's a pretty important character.

i talked to my friend a little about this chapter, and i was informed that this did not in fact make into the movie adaptation. i knew a bit more about the movies than i did the book, making this chapter completely out of left field, but it didn't surprise me that they had to make cuts. the trilogy is a pretty hefty series, and you can only fit so much into film adaptations. i plan on reading the whole book or even the trilogy to form an opinion on how i feel about various scenes or hell, maybe even characters that were cut from the movie, but for this scene specifically i think it's the scariest encounter they had (at this point in the narrative, i am aware they have many more scary encounters to go) other than the willow and the Dark Rider. to me i think the willow is a pretty close second, though. i think the movie "replaces" this scene with something that happens at the prancing pony, which im suspecting i'll find out soon enough and maybe then my thoughts on whether or not they should've made the cut will solidify, but so far my opinion on it is that i wonder if they still added barrow-wights to the films, and if not, i'll probably be a little bummed. i was curious at first how they looked in the film before my friend informed me this chapter was cut.

now ok time to wander more into nitpick territory—someone has to tell me whether i just don't know how to read maps or if i have an edition that doesn't include this bc i tried to follow along with them wherever they were going because on the map at the start of book 1 i could NOT find bree or the barrow-down for the fucking life of me. also maybe im just american and i haven't read in a while but it took a while to try to visualize where they were going and what the landmasses around them was like and what they were called. like i thought they went into a dip in the grass and the foggy stone was in the middle of it and that's where they had their picnic. anyway, im excited to read the next chapter, as i think im nearing the end of book 1 and things will start to amp up soon enough! idk if anyone even reads this but! if u did uh. thanks <3


0 Kudos

Comments

Displaying 0 of 0 comments ( View all | Add Comment )