Post Cold-War America Chose to Be on Top of a Broken World Rather than Shape A Better One

Post Cold-War America Chose to Be on Top of a Broken World Rather than Shape A Better One

or

The Unipolar Moment: How Post-Cold War America Cemented Hierarchies Instead of Transforming Them

The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 presented a historical inflection point unprecedented in modern geopolitics. As the sole remaining superpower, the United States possessed unrivaled military, economic, and cultural influence to reshape global systems fundamentally. Rather than dismantling entrenched hierarchies or forging new political, economic, and cultural paradigms, however, America consciously chose to position itself atop existing power structures - perpetuating and intensifying systems of capitalism, colonialism, and neoliberalism while inadvertently paving a highway toward resurgent fascism. America's post-Cold War decisions constituted a deliberate consolidation of power that preserved inequitable global systems rather than reimagining them for collective human advancement.

1. The Illusion of Unipolar Opportunity and the Reality of Hegemonic Consolidation

The triumphalist rhetoric of the "end of history" masked a calculated project of hegemonic entrenchment. Francis Fukuyama's famous thesis proclaimed liberal democracy's ultimate victory, suggesting an inevitable global convergence toward Western models. In practice, however, American policymakers interpreted unipolarity not as an opportunity to foster pluralistic development but as license to enforce a uniform global order under U.S. supremacy. Fritz Bartel's analysis reveals how the economic shocks of the 1970s had already pressured both superpowers to discipline their social contracts, with the United States adopting neoliberal austerity under Reagan and Thatcher. When the Soviet collapse eliminated ideological competition, America accelerated these policies globally through institutions like the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, making market fundamentalism the price of admission to the new world order. Rather than supporting diverse developmental paths, the U.S. leveraged its "peace dividend" into structural adjustment programs that pried open markets for American capital - extending colonial-era extraction through financialized means. The promise of democratic flourishing gave way to what political scientist William Robinson termed "promote democracy" interventions that installed compliant regimes preserving neoliberal orthodoxy and American primacy.

2. The Neoliberal Crusade: From Economic Doctrine to Global Captivity

Neoliberalism became the primary vehicle for cementing American dominance while masquerading as universal economic wisdom. Defined as extending "competitive markets into all areas of life, including the economy, politics and society," neoliberalism operated through a triad of policies: privatization, deregulation, and trade liberalization. The so-called Washington Consensus emerged as America's blueprint for the post-Soviet world, imposing shock therapy on former communist states and developing nations alike. As the search results document, these policies were "designed to increase the role of the private sector in the economy and society" while actively "re-tasking the role of the state" toward market-enabling rather than welfare-provisioning functions. The consequences were catastrophic for equality:  

- Corporate Sovereignty: State assets were transferred to private (often foreign) owners at fire-sale prices, creating oligarchic classes dependent on U.S. approval. Russia's post-1991 "reforms" exemplified this pillage, with GDP collapsing nearly 50% as public wealth concentrated in kleptocratic hands.  
- Deregulatory Race to the Bottom: Financial markets were unleashed from oversight, enabling the 2008 global crisis while cementing Wall Street's dominance. Labor protections were dismantled as "market rigidities," suppressing wages worldwide.  
- Asymmetric Trade Liberalization: America championed "free trade" that forced developing nations to eliminate tariffs while maintaining U.S. agricultural subsidies. The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) exemplified this, devastating Mexican campesinos through subsidized corn dumping while enabling cross-border profit repatriation.  

Crucially, these policies were never politically neutral. As Michel Foucault recognized and the Mont Pelerin Society originally envisioned, neoliberalism constituted a political project to entrench elite power. The "strong and impartial state" neoliberalism required proved to be one that disciplined populations for market efficiency while insulating economic policy from democratic accountability. America's unipolar moment enabled this doctrine's globalization, binding nations into a financialized hierarchy with Wall Street at its apex.

3. Cultural Homogenization and the Colonial Continuum

America's cultural ascendancy further reinforced structural inequalities under the guise of cosmopolitan modernity. The "soft power" celebrated by Joseph Nye operated as cultural imperialism, supplanting local traditions with consumerist individualism. Hollywood narratives, fast-food culture, and English linguistic dominance became tools for normalizing American-centric values while eroding alternative epistemologies. This cultural project bore striking continuities with colonial civilizing missions:  

- Knowledge Hegemony: Western institutions became the exclusive validators of expertise, marginalizing indigenous and Southern knowledge systems. Economics departments from Santiago to Mumbai taught American textbooks presenting neoliberalism as scientific truth.  
- Resource Extraction 2.0: Traditional colonialism's plunder continued through new mechanisms: intellectual property regimes that patented ancestral medicines, "free trade" agreements enabling land grabs, and dollar hegemony that exported inflation. The 1994 WTO Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) exemplified this, converting biological and cultural commons into corporate property.  
- Military Colonialism: Permanent bases in over 80 countries and interventions from Kosovo to Afghanistan demonstrated how U.S. "forward presence" updated colonial garrisoning. The 2003 Iraq invasion, marketed as democratization, ultimately secured oil access through client-state installation.  

Post-Cold War globalization thus constituted what anthropologist Anna Tsing termed "empire by replication" - a system where nations were compelled to reconstruct their institutions in America's image while remaining in subordinate positions within the global hierarchy.

4. The Fascist Drift: Neoliberalism's Authoritarian Turn

The structural violence of America's global order inevitably cultivated conditions for fascism's resurgence - both domestically and among allied states. Neoliberalism's erosion of social solidarity and manufactured precarity created fertile ground for authoritarian solutions:  

- Corporate-State Mergers: As Naomi Klein documented, the "shock doctrine" exploited crises to impose unpopular policies, from Pinochet's Chile to Yeltsin's Russia. This pattern normalized the suspension of democracy for capital security.  
- Surveillance Capitalism: Post-9/11 security states fused corporate data-mining with state repression, creating architectures of social control Silicon Valley profitably exported globally.  
- Exclusionary Nationalism: Neoliberalism's inequality explosion bred ethnonationalist backlashes. Trumpism's rise reflected not a break from but an outgrowth of neoliberal abandonment - channeling white working-class despair into xenophobia rather than class solidarity.  

By dismantling social contracts while enriching elites, America's model generated the very instability that justified its militarized permanence. The "war on terror" became the perfect alibi for illiberal governance, with Guantanamo Bay and drone assassinations demonstrating democracy's expendability when hegemony was threatened.

Conclusion: The Road Not Taken and the Path Ahead

America squandered its unipolar moment not through absence of vision but through conscious choice to entrench rather than transform. Alternatives existed: a peace dividend funding global green transitions; multilateral institutions redesigned for equitable development; cultural exchange fostering pluralistic modernities. Instead, the Clinton administration's embrace of financialization, NATO expansionism, and welfare retrenchment cemented the neoliberal-authoritarian trajectory.  

The consequences now manifest in the "polycrisis" Adam Tooze describes - climate chaos, democratic backsliding, and resurgent great-power conflict. Even America's recent "post-neoliberal" turn under Biden - with its industrial policy and "friend-shoring" - prioritizes national advantage over systemic equity. The highway to fascism that worries the user appears less a wrong turn than the logical destination of a system designed to preserve hierarchy. Transforming this path requires confronting not merely policy choices but the very logic of supremacy that animated America's lost unipolar moment. Only by dismantling the myth of benevolent hegemony can we begin building systems worthy of human potential.

Sources – Read These for a Fuller Understanding

1. Books & Academic Works

• Bartel, Fritz – The Triumph of Broken Promises: The End of the Cold War and the Rise of Neoliberalism (Harvard University Press, 2022).

  • Harvard University Press Page

• Fukuyama, Francis – The End of History and the Last Man (Free Press, 1992).

  • Publisher’s Page

• Robinson, William I. – Promoting Polyarchy: Globalization, US Intervention, and Hegemony (Cambridge University Press, 1996).

  • Cambridge University Press Page

• Foucault, Michel – The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1978–1979 (Picador, 2008).

  • Publisher’s Page

• Klein, Naomi – The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism (Metropolitan Books, 2007).

  • Naomi Klein’s Official Site

• Tsing, Anna – Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection (Princeton University Press, 2005).

  • Princeton University Press Page

• Tooze, Adam – Shutdown: How Covid Shook the World’s Economy (Viking, 2021).

  • Adam Tooze’s Columbia Page

2. Articles & Reports

• Nye, Joseph S. – "Soft Power" (Foreign Policy, 1990).

  • Foreign Policy Archive

• Williamson, John – "What Washington Means by Policy Reform" (Peterson Institute for International Economics, 1990) – (Original Washington Consensus paper).

  • PIIE PDF

• Mont Pelerin Society – Foundational neoliberal think tank.

  • Official Site

3. Policy & Historical Documents

• North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA, 1994) – Full text available via U.S. government archives.

  • USTR NAFTA Page

• WTO TRIPS Agreement (1994) – Intellectual property enforcement mechanism.

  • WTO TRIPS Page

4. News & Analysis

• "The Washington Consensus" – Overview from The Economist.

  • The Economist (2003)

• "Neoliberalism: The Idea That Swallowed the World" – The Guardian (2017).

  • The Guardian Article