Your immortal lover would be...

Poseidon

The sea is vast and deep, both enticing and unwelcoming. You tend to be attracted to people who seem larger than life itself, great people who are vast and mysterious, like the sea.

Amy Lee

Though cool and intimidating on the outside- you're a very kind and empathetic person on the inside. You're naturally inspiring, and many people want to emulate you. You're also a very quiet and private person, which might diminish your true potential. Don't be afraid to break out of your shell!